Homer's Iliad and the Trojan War: Dialogues on Tradition

Description

In this new volume, Jan Haywood and Naoise Mac Sweeney investigate the position of Homer's Iliad within the wider Trojan War tradition through a series of detailed case studies. From ancient Mesopotamia to twenty-first century America, these examples are drawn from a range of historical and cultural contexts; and from Athenian pot paintings to twelfth-century German scholarship, they engage with a range of different media and genres. Inspired by the dialogues inherent in the process of reception, the book adopts a dialogic structure. In each chapter, paired essays by Haywood and Mac Sweeney offer contrasting authorial voices addressing a single theme, thereby drawing out connections and dissonances between a diverse suite of classical and post-classical Iliadic receptions. The resulting book offers new insights, both into individual instances of Iliadic reception in particular historical contexts, but also into the workings of a complex story tradition. The centrality of the Iliad within the wider Trojan War tradition is shown to be a function of conscious engagement not only with Iliadic content, but also with Iliadic status and the iconic idea of the Homeric.

Jan Haywood is Lecturer in Classical Studies at the Open University, UK. He has published on various aspects of the history and literature of the ancient Greek world, and is the author of Intertext and Allusion in Herodotus'Histories: Authority, Proof, Polemic (forthcoming). Naoise Mac Sweeney is Associate Professor in Ancient History at the University of Leicester, UK. Her published titles include Foundation Myths and Politics in Ancient Ionia (2013) and Community Identity and Archaeology (2011).

The range is impressive ... Iliadic reception processes churn in these pages as diverse post-classical connections and dissonances are illuminated. Bound together then, as privileged, the epic of Homer and the whole tradition of the Trojan War, retold and reiterated, confirm at once their complexity and centrality. The authors show how, over time, what prevails is a conscious engagement with Iliadic content, Iliadic status, and the iconic idea of the Homeric ... Summing Up: Recommended. * CHOICE * A thought-provoking, carefully considered series of case studies that make it a worthwhile read for anyone with an interest in Classical reception. * Minerva * Haywood and Mac Sweeney's engaging book performs a spirited scholarly dialogue about the extraordinary role of the Iliad in shaping several Trojan War receptions that respond by forever transforming the very source text they evoke. * Monica S. Cyrino, Professor of Classics, University of New Mexico, USA * For classical scholars wishing to test the waters of reception studies (perhaps for teaching purposes), the book offers an impressively varied array of entry points. At least one topic - and more likely several - ought to be of interest to any given scholar. Anyone wanting to enrich a university-level course on epic will find here a set of ready-made topics, issues (suggested by the discussion of the section themes) and avenues for further reading (in the footnotes). As each essay gives considerable attention to historical and cultural context, many could also be assigned as fair introductions to the particular works with which they deal: the essays on the Erra and on Schliemann come to mind especially here. Moreover, the book's accessible prose style(s) and (almost perfectly) consistent translation of Greek and Latin terms may make it an attractive option for students and scholars in other disciplines whose interests include Trojan War materials. * The Classical Association *